As a donor, you have every right to understand where your contributions are going and how effectively they are used. Transparency in charitable organizations is crucial for ensuring that your donations truly fulfill their intended purpose. One significant tool for gauging a charity’s financial health is Form 990, the annual tax return filed by nonprofits that is publicly accessible.
This guide will walk you through the essential components of Form 990, so you can feel empowered to analyze a charity's fiscal responsibility. We’ll highlight key sections to examine, explain what they signify, and help you develop a critical eye for evaluating the efficiency and integrity of charities you consider supporting.
Step-by-step walkthrough
Retrieve the Form 990
Visit ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer (projects.propublica.org/nonprofits) to easily access the Form 990 for any charity. Enter the charity's name or EIN to pull up its filings, which are available for public review.
Examine Part I: Summary
This section gives an overview of the organization's mission, revenues, and expenses. Look for total revenue, total expenses, and the net assets to assess the charity’s financial health at a glance.
Analyze Part IX: Functional Expenses
Here, you'll find a breakdown of how the charity allocates its funds. A well-run charity typically spends 75% or more of its expenses on program services rather than administration or fundraising, indicating effective resource use.
Review Schedule J: Executive Compensation
This schedule lists the salaries of top executives. Compare these figures to the charity's size and revenue to determine if compensation appears reasonable relative to the mission and financial situation.
Flag Schedule L: Related-Party Transactions
Look for any transactions that may involve board members or executives. This section can reveal potential conflicts of interest or self-dealing, which are critical to understand when evaluating a charity.
Positive signals (green flags)
✓ High Program Expense Ratio
A charity that spends 75% or more on direct program services demonstrates a commitment to maximizing the impact of donations, signaling responsible financial management.
✓ Reasonable Executive Compensation
If the salaries listed in Schedule J align with industry standards and the charity's revenue size, it indicates that the organization values fiscal responsibility.
✓ Transparent Governance Structure
A well-documented board governance structure is a positive indicator. Look for clear bylaws, meeting minutes, and diverse board representation which suggest accountability.
✓ Consistent Year-over-Year Growth
If a charity shows stable growth in revenue and program services, it indicates strong management and community trust, essential for ongoing support and mission accomplishment.
Warning signals (red flags)
⚠ High Administrative Costs
If a charity spends significantly more on administration and fundraising than on programs, it may indicate inefficiency. Look for expenses exceeding 25% of total spending allocated to admin or fundraising.
⚠ Excessive Executive Salaries
When executive compensation is disproportionately high compared to the charity's overall revenue, it raises questions about whether funds are being utilized for their intended charitable purpose.
⚠ Related-Party Transactions
If there are numerous transactions listed in Schedule L involving board members or their businesses, it could suggest potential conflicts of interest or unethical practices worth investigating.
⚠ Lack of Major Donor Disclosure
Absence of major funding sources or grantmakers can be a red flag. It's important to know where a charity's funding comes from to ensure its sustainability and integrity.
Tools + resources
- https://www.propublica.org/nonprofits
- https://www.guidestar.org
- https://www.irs.gov/app/eos
- https://www.charitynavigator.org
- https://bbb.org/charity-reviews
- https://www.afpnet.org
St. Louis state-level oversight
In St. Louis and across Missouri, transparency in charitable giving is vital for building trust. The Missouri Attorney General’s office maintains a charitable registry for oversight, ensuring charities comply with state laws. Additionally, local chapters like the Better Business Bureau provide charity reviews, while associations like the Missouri Nonprofit Association offer resources to support ethical practices within the sector, helping donors make informed choices.
FAQ
What is Form 990?
Where can I find a charity's Form 990?
What key sections should I focus on?
How can I determine if a charity is financially healthy?
What are related-party transactions?
Why is executive compensation important?
How can I compare charities effectively?
Other donor-verification guides
Before making a donation, take the time to understand the charity's financial practices through Form 990. Empower yourself with knowledge to ensure that your contributions make a lasting impact in the St. Louis community. By analyzing the data, you can support organizations that are transparent, effective, and committed to their mission.